Late August through September is the best time to overseed in New York and the Northeast. Around Westchester, aim for the last two weeks of August through mid-September, and try to be done by early October. Spring works too, but it's a distant second.
Fall is when cool-season grass wants to grow. The soil is still warm from summer, so seed sprouts fast. The air is cooler, so young grass doesn’t cook. And most weeds are done for the year, so nothing’s competing.
New grass also gets two cool seasons (fall and spring) to build roots before its first summer. Spring seed gets zero.
The Timing, by Month
Mid to late August: the best window. Water bills are the only downside.
September: still great. Most people around here seed Labor Day weekend.
Early October: OK with fast grass (perennial ryegrass). Getting risky.
Mid-October on: too late for most lawns. Save the seed for next year.
My Can I seed now? tool checks your soil temperature and gives a straight yes or no.
How to Overseed, Step by Step
Pick the right seed. Match it to your sun and how you use the yard. Pick your grass in four taps.
Mow short. Drop the mower to about 2 to 2.5 inches for this one mow, and bag the clippings.
Get seed to soil. Core aerate, or rake hard with a metal rake until you see dirt between the grass. Seed sitting on top of thatch won’t grow.
Spread the seed. Use about half the new-lawn rate on the bag. Go in two directions so you don’t miss stripes. How much do I need?
Feed it. Use a starter fertilizer (the middle number on the bag is bigger). How to read a bag.
Water lightly and often. Keep the top inch damp, one to three short waterings a day, until it’s up.
Wait. Ryegrass shows up in about a week. Fescue in one to two. Bluegrass can take three or four. Is my seed working?
First mow when the new grass hits about 4 inches. Sharp blade, dry soil.
Don’t Do These
Don’t put down a regular crabgrass preventer within a few months of seeding. It stops grass seed too. Read the label for the wait time.
Don’t kill weeds the same week you seed. Most weed sprays say to wait a few weeks before seeding. Weeds or seed first?
Don’t let it dry out in the first two weeks. That’s how most seed dies.
Common Questions
Is October too late to overseed?
Early October is usually OK in the Lower Hudson Valley if you use fast grass like perennial ryegrass. By mid-October the soil is cooling and young grass may not be tough enough for winter. If you missed it, wait for next August or try spring.
Can I overseed in the spring?
You can, but it's harder. Weeds sprout at the same time, summer heat hits young grass before its roots are deep, and most crabgrass preventers stop grass seed too. If you seed in spring, skip the regular crabgrass preventer.
How much grass seed do I need to overseed?
About half the rate for a brand-new lawn. That's roughly 2 to 4 pounds per 1,000 square feet depending on the grass. The bag lists both rates. My lawn calculator does the math for your yard.
Do I need to aerate before overseeding?
It helps a lot, but it's not required. Seed needs to touch soil. Core aerating, hard raking or a dethatcher all get you there. Aerating is the best of the three.
How often should I water new grass seed?
Keep the top inch of soil damp until the grass is up. That's usually a light watering one to three times a day for two to three weeks. Once it's growing, water less often and deeper.