Pre-emergent vs. post-emergent: the bouncer and the hitman
Pre-emergent weed control stops weeds before they sprout. Post-emergent kills weeds you can see. What each one does, when to use it, why timing is everything, and why most pre-emergents also stop grass seed.
Pre-emergent stops weeds before they sprout. Post-emergent kills weeds you can already see. One is a bouncer at the door. The other is a hitman. You need to know which one you’re hiring.
Pre-emergent: the bouncer
Pre-emergent sits in the top layer of soil and stops seeds from sprouting. Crabgrass preventer is the one everybody knows.
- It does nothing to weeds that are already up. Zero. The bouncer doesn’t throw out people already inside.
- Timing is everything. Down too late and the crabgrass already sprouted. Around here, put it down when soil hits about 55°F, roughly when forsythia blooms. Usually April.
- Water it in within a few days so it gets into the soil.
- It lasts a few months, then it’s gone.
- It stops grass seed too. Big one. More on that below.
Post-emergent: the hitman
Post-emergent kills weeds that are already growing.
- Broadleaf weed killers take out dandelions, clover, plantain and friends without killing grass. That’s called “selective.”
- Crabgrass killers take out crabgrass that’s already up. They work best on young plants.
- Kill-everything sprays take out everything, including your lawn. Use those for starting over, not for weeds.
Best time to hire the hitman for dandelions and clover: fall. Weeds are pulling energy into their roots for winter, and the weed killer goes right along.
The catch nobody mentions
Most pre-emergents can’t tell a crabgrass seed from a grass seed. Put down crabgrass preventer in April and you’re mostly not seeding those spots until fall.
Want both? There are seed-safe options. Here’s how to seed and fight weeds in the same season.
Which one do I need?
The bottom line
Bouncer in April. Hitman in fall. And the best security system there is? Thick grass mowed tall. Weeds can’t move in when there’s no vacancy. Name that weed.