Granules vs. spray: I hate spraying, and I’m not sorry
Granular or liquid for fertilizer, crabgrass preventer and weed killer? The honest pros and cons of each, what happened when I tried spray dye and surfactants, and when spraying actually wins.
Granules for almost everything. A spray bottle for the odd weed. That’s my whole system. Spraying is messy, it’s easy to miss spots, and you can’t see where you’ve been. Some people swear by it. I respect them. I don’t want to be them.
Granules: the good and the bad
Good:
- Easy. Fill the spreader, walk, done.
- You can see them. You know where you’ve been.
- Slow-release granules keep feeding for weeks.
- Forgiving. A little overlap won’t usually ruin your life.
Bad:
- You need a spreader, and a spreader can draw stripes on your lawn. (Here’s how I fix that.)
- Granular weed killers need wet leaves to stick and a dry day after. Annoying.
- Bags are heavy. A 50 lb bag is a workout I didn’t ask for.
Spray: the good and the bad
Good:
- Works fast. Weed killer coats the leaf and gets to work.
- Spot spraying is precise. Hit the dandelion, skip everything else.
- Concentrates go a long way, so they can be cheaper per square foot.
Bad:
- Mixing. Measuring. Funnels. Gloves.
- You can’t see where you sprayed. Clear liquid on green grass. Good luck.
- Wind takes it where you didn’t want it.
- Cleaning the sprayer after. Every. Single. Time.
- Everyone stays off the lawn until it dries.
The time I tried to make spraying work
I gave it a real shot. I added marker dye so I could see where I’d sprayed, and a surfactant to help it stick to the leaves and work better.
Did it help? A little. Was it worth it? Not for me. The dye got on my hands, my shoes, the driveway and somehow the dog. The surfactant made everything slippery. I spent more time cleaning up than spraying. I went back to granules and never looked back.
When spray actually wins
I’m not a zealot. Spray is the right call when:
- You’ve got a few weeds. A ready-to-use spray bottle is the easiest weed control there is. Even I keep one in the garage.
- Weeds are everywhere and already growing. Liquid works better than weed-and-feed on established weeds.
- You want fast iron green-up before a party. Liquid iron darkens grass in days.
- You like gear. Some people love dialing in a backpack sprayer. God bless.
Tap the job to see my pick:
The bottom line
If you hate chores, use granules. If you love gear, go ahead and spray. Either way, read the label and keep kids and dogs off until it’s dry. What’s safe and what’s not.