Do you actually need it? A brutally honest list of lawn stuff your neighbor bought
Aeration, aeration sneakers, dethatchers, mulching blades, lawn stripers, lime, iron, top dressing, irrigation and more: what’s worth it, what’s a maybe, and what’s a scam, from a guy who bought most of it.
Sharpen your blade and get a soil test. Almost everything else is a maybe or a no. Your neighbor’s garage is full of stuff that doesn’t matter. I know because mine is too.
Here’s every piece of lawn stuff people ask me about, with my honest verdict. Tap the thing:
The short version
- Yes: blade sharpening, a soil test.
- Maybe: aeration (only if your soil is packed), mulching blades, a striper kit (only if you want stripes, and you do), iron (before a party).
- Only with a soil test: lime.
- Probably not: dethatching, top dressing, an irrigation system, grub killer every single year.
- Absolutely not: aeration sneakers.
About those aeration sneakers
I bought them. They’re spiked sandals you strap over your shoes and walk around in. The idea is you poke holes in the lawn while you do yard work.
The reality: spikes just push the dirt sideways. Real aeration pulls little plugs of soil out. To make any difference, you’d have to walk every inch of your lawn a bunch of times. You will not do that. Nobody will do that. You will, however, look like a lawn villain, and your wife will take pictures. Ask me how I know.
The rule for anything new
Before you buy something, ask: what problem does this fix, and do I have that problem? Most lawn problems come from mowing too short, feeding at the wrong time, or never seeding. None of those need new gear.
Mow tall. Feed on the holidays. Seed in fall. Then buy toys.